LUMEN HOUSE ESSAYS

Free download

The illustrated Lumen House essay edition.

This essay places the episode of Argos in Homer’s Odyssey in conversation with The Merits of Dogs over Many of Those Who Wear Clothes, the tenth-century Abbasid work of Muḥammad ibn Khalaf ibn al-Marzubān (d. 309/921). It examines how the neglected dog at the threshold of Odysseus’s palace exposes the moral disorder of a household marked by indulgence within and abandonment without.

The essay distinguishes carefully between what Homer records and the intimate companionship later readers have imaginatively supplied. Argos recognises Odysseus beneath his disguise and then dies, but Homer does not develop the episode into an explicit philosophy of canine virtue. Ibn al-Marzubān, by contrast, deliberately gathers poetry, reports, anecdotes and wit to compare the loyalty, gratitude and usefulness of dogs with the failures of wicked human companions. His satire turns upon the unsettling distance between the outward appearance of civilisation and the conduct that should confirm it.

This illustrated Lumen House Essay Edition includes supplementary marginalia on Homeric geography and reception, Plato’s treatment of canine discernment, Ibn al-Marzubān and adab, key Arabic expressions, and the place of thje infamous Iblīs within Islamic tradition.

​